Kitchen

A Mehlspeise is not a pudding

A slice of strudel on a plate in low light

Look under "Mehlspeisen" on an Austrian menu expecting desserts and you will find dishes that would be main courses anywhere else. That is not a translation error. It is a different way of dividing up a meal.

This separate category is one of the things that sets Austrian cooking apart from most of Europe — something what makes a classic a classic follows up.

A meal in itself, not a finish

Kaiserschmarrn, Germknödel, Topfenpalatschinken, apricot dumplings: these are not portions that arrive after a main course. A Kaiserschmarrn with stewed plums is lunch, and one after which nobody needs anything else.

The reason is historical and mundane. Sweet food was long the cheaper meal — flour, milk, eggs and fruit from the garden were easier to come by than meat. Meat-free days in the church calendar did the rest. Necessity became a category, and the category became a speciality.

It also explains the portion sizes that reliably astonish visitors. A Mehlspeise is not designed as the final third of a three-course meal.

Strudel and the question of pastry

Strudel dough is the most technically demanding thing in this category, and it is made of flour, water, oil and salt. Nothing else.

What defines it is that it is stretched until you could read a newspaper through it. That only works because the dough has been kneaded at length and then rested: kneading builds the gluten structure, resting lets it relax. Without the rest it tears while being pulled; without the kneading it will not hold.

Puff pastry is a different thing and makes a different strudel — not worse, but not the same. A stretched strudel has thin, soft layers that wrap around the filling; a puff pastry one has a flaky shell that stands on its own.

Topfen is the difference

Topfen strudel is more common in Vienna than apple strudel, and Topfen — a fresh curd cheese — is a load-bearing ingredient in this kitchen. It is sharper and less fatty than most soft cheeses, and that is exactly what makes it useful: it does not add to the sweetness, it pushes back against it.

The whole balance of the category hangs on that. A Mehlspeise with no acidity — no Topfen, no plums, no apricots, no squeeze of lemon — turns monotonously sweet very quickly. The same logic as the savoury plate, applied in reverse, as described in dumplings, potato salad and the rest of the plate.

The three families

The category sorts roughly into three groups, which helps when reading a menu.

The pastry ones: strudel, Palatschinken, Buchteln, Germknödel. They live on a dough that is either stretched, cooked thin, or raised with yeast.

The egg ones: Kaiserschmarrn, baked puddings, Schmarren of every kind. Here beaten eggs carry the structure, which is why they have to be served the moment they are cooked — they collapse.

And the fruit ones: apricot dumplings, stewed fruit, compotes. These are the most tightly bound to the season. Apricot dumplings exist when there are apricots and not otherwise. Anyone offering them in January is working from frozen fruit or compote, and you can taste it.

Warm is part of the dish

Nearly all of these are eaten warm, and that is not a detail. Warm strudel has soft pastry and a filling that smells of something; cold strudel is a cake. Kaiserschmarrn has to come straight out of the pan or it collapses.

For a kitchen that means these dishes can only be prepared so far in advance. The strudel can be finished, but the slice still has to go back into the oven. It is the same constraint that applies to anything crumbed.

What goes with it

Very little. A vanilla sauce, some whipped cream, icing sugar. Stewed fruit, when there is fruit for it. What does not belong is a plate full of components — a Mehlspeise is already the dish, not the centre of an arrangement.

And when one does follow a main course, it should come in a portion that accounts for what went before. That is the only point at which the category has to negotiate with the rest of the menu: half a Kaiserschmarrn after a schnitzel is a sensible idea, a whole one rarely is.

Book a table, ideally with room left for one.

Share this post
Book a table(opens in a new tab)