Bar

Choosing wine with food

A long table laid with wine glasses beside vines

Matching wine to food is treated as an expert subject, which is exactly why most guests would rather not ask. In fact two rules carry surprisingly far, and the third one everybody has heard is the weakest of them.

Why we pour mostly Austrian wine while doing it is in our guide to them.

First rule: acidity against fat

The most useful rule there is, and the same one that puts a lemon beside a schnitzel in the kitchen. Fat coats the palate; acidity clears it again.

In practice: the fattier, more crumbed or creamier the dish, the more acidity the wine can carry. A schnitzel therefore wants a Veltliner rather than a soft, worked white, which turns dull beside the fat immediately.

The same arithmetic sits behind every side dish in our kitchen — dumplings, potato salad and the rest of the plate sets it out for the plate.

Second rule: weight against weight

A heavy wine flattens a light dish; a light wine disappears beside a heavy one. That is obvious and still the mistake people make most often.

Steamed fish does not want a dense red; beef braised for three hours does not want a light tavern wine. There is plenty of room in between, but the extremes rarely go well.

Weight here is not alcohol alone but the sum of alcohol, extract, tannin and oak. A wine at thirteen per cent with no oak reads as lighter than one at the same number from a new barrel.

The rule you can forget

"White with fish, red with meat" is the best known and the least useful. It happens to be right often, because fish is usually light and meat usually heavy — but it describes the wrong variable.

A light chilled Zweigelt suits pan-fried zander well. A full-bodied white suits roast pork well. What decides it is weight and acidity, not colour — more on that in Zweigelt and Blaufränkisch.

Sweet with sweet, not sweet with dry

The exception most people come unstuck on: puddings. A dry wine beside something sweet reads as sour and thin, because the sugar in the food shifts the perception.

So the rule is that the wine has to be at least as sweet as the dessert. A Ruster Ausbruch or a Beerenauslese beside a Topfenstrudel works; a dry Riesling does not. Why sweet food is a category of its own in Austria anyway is in a Mehlspeise is not a pudding.

What makes a dish difficult

Three things reliably interfere with wine.

Vinegar, and therefore any dressing. Acidity in food makes wine taste flat, which is why a sharply dressed salad makes almost any wine look bad. Wanting both means a wine with even more acidity — a Styrian white, for instance.

Heat amplifies the perception of alcohol. Spicy food suits light, cool, faintly sweet wines better than strong dry ones.

Artichoke and asparagus contain compounds that make many wines taste metallic or oddly sweet. With asparagus, Veltliner and Sauvignon Blanc work best — what makes asparagus season so short explains why those weeks come with their own arithmetic anyway.

Two approaches that nearly always work

When the rules run out, there are two fallbacks.

The first: what grows together goes together. Dishes and wines from the same area developed alongside each other over generations, and it shows. Austrian wine suits Austrian classics almost automatically, and an Italian white suits a bruschetta.

The second: the sauce decides, not the meat. Chicken with lemon and herbs and chicken in a cream sauce are two different dishes as far as wine is concerned. When in doubt, look at whatever is liquid on the plate.

One sentence is enough at the table

Nobody has to study a list. "We are having schnitzel and a salad, what goes with that?" is a complete question, and a house that knows its eight wines by the glass answers it in five seconds.

And when a table is eating different things, wine by the glass is the answer rather than a bottle — everyone gets what suits their plate. Why we keep a short list for that is in wine by the glass, and why it is honest.

Book a table and just ask.

Share this post
Book a table(opens in a new tab)